How Readers Make Decisions What to Buy

I hope you aren’t disappointed in the promise that I appear to make in today’s headline… I do not have the definitive, magic formula to successfully convince people to buy your book.  Like building an author platform, the answer is actually boring and possibly frustrating if you are in a hurry to be a success at writing. (It is always a good idea to lower expectations at the outset of anything (which I learned being a lifelong Chicago Cubs fan).

What I do know is that regardless of other changes in publishing, one factor remains constant for not-yet-known authors or unfamiliar books::

People buy an unfamiliar book primarily based on recommendations from others.

The strength of credibility for that recommendation might vary depending on whether it is a close friend, respected authority or an anonymous online review, but still, buyers do not buy in a vacuum.  They are influenced by someone else.

Unlike last week when I outlined how decisions are made by agents and publishers (quick and subjective), readers make the decision to buy a new book based on what they were told.  While you can’t tell a book by its cover, you most certain will buy it without reading it first. So, we rely on others.

“I heard this was a good book”

“My friend said I should read this.”

“My pastor recommended this book.”

“I heard the author interviewed”

“This is the best book I’ve read on this subject.”

Consumers are careful with their money. They pay attention to what other people say. Libraries are good for low-risk testing of something, but buying a book is an entirely different process.

An author friend of mine tends to ignore reviews from media and other professional reviewers because, “I don’t pay attention to anyone who gets their books for free.”

When someone puts down their own money to buy a book and still recommends it, greater weight should be given that review.

After you buy a first book from a certain author, whether you will buy their next book or not is based on your reading experience. It’s how any business, TV program, church or anything depending on repeat business grows…you need to make people want to come back and recommend it to others.

Every successful first book from an author is built in the same way. First-readers liked it and mentioned it to friends.  Media or well-known endorsers help to get the ball rolling to an extent, but no marketing campaign carries the power of a trusted friend recommending a book.

Authors who self-publish live in the same world as those traditionally published. They still need to impress a small group of people enough for them to recommend it to someone else.  It is how any business is built, whether you clean rugs for a living or write books.

Furthermore, using a business principle not specific to publishing, but still true, selling price should not be the most compelling argument for someone to buy your product over another.

Do you want to be the best rug cleaner in your area or the cheapest?

Do you want people to read your books and be positively affected by them or be able to say you gave away 40,000 free ebooks?  (Just because 40,000 people downloaded it doesn’t mean that number read it. I am not against “seeding the market” with a price promotion, but it is very limited and should result in increased paid downloads.)

Sometimes the answer to the above questions is “both”, but not usually. In general, you choose one or the other. The road to success in writing or rug cleaning is a slow process of one step at a time. Impress one, which then becomes two, then four, eight, sixteen, thirty-two, etc.

There are no shortcuts to success that lasts.


Leave a Comment

Justin Beiber and Leisure Suits

Recognizing the difference between a cultural “trend” and a “phenomenon” is an important skill of anyone working in book publishing, both employees of publishers and authors. Why? Because book publishing in virtually every form does a very poor job responding to a phenomenon, which is generally short-lived. Often a phenomenon …

Read More

Synopsis Made Easy – I Promise!

Okay, fellow proposal peeps, it’s time to jump in and work together on crafting a perfect proposal. Many of you echoed what I’ve heard over and over through the years: “I hate writing the synopsis!” This is especially painful because you need a short synopsis/summary that runs around 50-60 words—but …

Read More

Weirdest Booksigning Experience

Came across today’s rather strange photo and thought it a good metaphor for the weird things that can, and have, happened at an author’s booksigning. Over the years I’ve either stood in line, organized, facilitated, or observed over 300 author booksignings. Everything from popular celebrities to a local self-published author trying …

Read More

Who is Your Audience?

Recently I went shopping for a new watch. Thankfully, I later discovered I could have the old one repaired and am taking that route. However, since I’m a literary agent, I can relate everything to books, so here goes. At high end stores a salesperson was immediately available. While I …

Read More

Publishers Are From Mercury, Authors are From Pluto

Next time someone tells you that Christianity is not as valid as science, just remind them that not many years ago, Pluto was assumed to be a planet, but in 2006 was determined not to be one, but instead was a “dwarf planet”, of which there a several dozen in …

Read More


One of the buzzwords you hear in publishing today is discoverability. Authors must be discovered by potential readers. To that end, even though obviously selling a car is much different from selling a book, I still think we might be able to learn some lessons from Maserati. I hadn’t thought …

Read More

Writer, Know Thyself!

I recently spent four days with a wonderful group of writers. We meet every year to pray together, brainstorm each other’s books, and laugh uproariously. I always come home feeling like I’ve had a major ab workout from all the laughter! In the course of our discussions, I realized that …

Read More

8 Things Authors Should No Longer Ask Their Publisher

Publishing is changing faster than ever before.  Book publishers have been wrenching to find new business models that make them more flexible, efficient and adaptable to the realities of the digital publishing age. Within this fast-change world, another group who has felt the pain of shifting tectonic plates are authors …

Read More

It’s Not Who You Know

From the third season of the 90’s sitcom Seinfeld, this classic interchange: Car Rental Agent: I’m sorry, we have no mid-size available at the moment.  Jerry: I don’t understand, I made a reservation, do you have my reservation? Agent: Yes, we do, unfortunately we ran out of cars. Jerry: But …

Read More