But My Critique Group Likes It!

Over the years, I have received this comment from frustrated authors when a work didn’t hit the mark with me. As someone who penned many books in the past myself, I understand and sympathize with these authors. However, this argument will almost  never get an author another read of the same manuscript — at least in my office. This is because though they are important, crit groups usually start out as a gathering of new authors banding together to help one another. Rarely is there a professional writer in the bunch.

But before you protest that isn’t so…

Yes, sometimes critique groups do have professional authors as members. But in the course of my 20 years in book publishing, I’ve only encountered a couple of groups where I could say, “Okay, if this went through your crit group, I can pretty much send your work to every editor I know without a second thought.” These crit groups are very rare and special things, and usually come about when one or two authors become successful among a group of genuine friends.

I wish I could set out a list of bullet items outlining how to form a crit group that will wow an agent. As suggested above, I can’t. My best advice is to make connections with people writing your type of book and enjoy the friendship, fellowship, and exchanged knowledge. After all, no one should choose friends based only on what they can do for you.

But I have a big name author in my group!

If this is the case, I believe it’s perfectly fine to mention that Bestselling Jane has is one of your critique partners, and there is a good possibility she will endorse your book. (Or maybe she has already promised, since she has read the book and would only need to write a blurb). Better still, perhaps Bestselling Jane could write a blurb to include in your proposal.

Even Bestselling Jane won’t ensure you’ll secure Dream Agent. However, her involvement with your work should  give you an advantage with the right agent.

Back to reality…

For writers in newbie groups, just know that yes, it’s great to send a proposal out with the confidence that it’s been gone over by other writers. And if your work doesn’t resonate with one agent, keep trying. Keep writing. And have fun!

Your turn

Are you in a critique group? Why or why not?

What are the advantages of critique groups, in your opinion?

What tips can you give other writers on forming and maintaining a successful  critique group?



Leave a Comment

Standing for Something

Take a Stand

When Al Ries and Jack Trout published their classic marketing book Positioning in 1981, the concept of the book and the single-word title became a white-hot marketing buzzword, much in the same way as “platform” is today. I am not going to dig into that classic business title today or …

Read More

Healthy Brain Food

In this social media-saturated world where everyone seems to have an opinion about everything, it is very important to quickly determine those voices you pay attention to and those you tune out. When it comes to the book publishing business, I narrow down who I pay attention to simply because …

Read More

How Readers Make Decisions What to Buy

I hope you aren’t disappointed in the promise that I appear to make in today’s headline… I do not have the definitive, magic formula to successfully convince people to buy your book.  Like building an author platform, the answer is actually boring and possibly frustrating if you are in a hurry to …

Read More

Justin Beiber and Leisure Suits

Recognizing the difference between a cultural “trend” and a “phenomenon” is an important skill of anyone working in book publishing, both employees of publishers and authors. Why? Because book publishing in virtually every form does a very poor job responding to a phenomenon, which is generally short-lived. Often a phenomenon …

Read More

Synopsis Made Easy – I Promise!

Okay, fellow proposal peeps, it’s time to jump in and work together on crafting a perfect proposal. Many of you echoed what I’ve heard over and over through the years: “I hate writing the synopsis!” This is especially painful because you need a short synopsis/summary that runs around 50-60 words—but …

Read More

Weirdest Booksigning Experience

Came across today’s rather strange photo and thought it a good metaphor for the weird things that can, and have, happened at an author’s booksigning. Over the years I’ve either stood in line, organized, facilitated, or observed over 300 author booksignings. Everything from popular celebrities to a local self-published author trying …

Read More

Who is Your Audience?

Recently I went shopping for a new watch. Thankfully, I later discovered I could have the old one repaired and am taking that route. However, since I’m a literary agent, I can relate everything to books, so here goes. At high end stores a salesperson was immediately available. While I …

Read More

Publishers Are From Mercury, Authors are From Pluto

Next time someone tells you that Christianity is not as valid as science, just remind them that not many years ago, Pluto was assumed to be a planet, but in 2006 was determined not to be one, but instead was a “dwarf planet”, of which there a several dozen in …

Read More


One of the buzzwords you hear in publishing today is discoverability. Authors must be discovered by potential readers. To that end, even though obviously selling a car is much different from selling a book, I still think we might be able to learn some lessons from Maserati. I hadn’t thought …

Read More