How Publishers Make Decisions

We all agree that book publishing is changing fast. New technology, new formats and new ways to sell books have changed everything.  Well, almost everything.

One thing has not changed…the fundamental way decisions are made as to what new authors an agent represents and publishers publish. It has always been and remains people making quick, subjective decisions (aka QSD).

A number of years ago I knew a publisher that received 5,000 unsolicited book proposals and manuscripts each year.  Those were the days before email submissions were common, so you can imagine the piles of paper. If each of those were to be thoroughly reviewed and researched, the company would have needed to hire 15 full-time employees for that purpose alone with the very real possibility than none of the 5,000 would make the final cut for the publisher.

So what happened? Decisions to review some of them more thoroughly were based on first impressions.  If at first glance it wouldn’t fit the company, it wasn’t given any further thought.  A quick, subjective decision was made.

Agents get a lot of submissions from new and prospective authors as well.  Hundreds or thousands per year.  Here again, the only way to deal with that is to filter out most with a QSD.

Writers’ conferences contain examples of what I am talking about, by scheduling 15 minutes of time with an agent or editor to “speed-review” your proposal. It is good exposure for how quick decisions are made.  Actually, to more accurately simulate what really happens, the meetings should be more like 90 seconds, but I am not sure anyone would desire to take part in that chaos!

There have been some changes to parts of the publisher decision-process. A little more than ten years ago, sales data from various bookselling channels for all published titles became available, so publishers could analyze comparable titles and also specific author sales history to make smarter decisions on what books to acquire.

But the decision to publish a new author or any new book remains a subjective process, meaning that sometimes logic plays a very minor part in the decision.

For example, what is good writing? It is a personal, subjective judgment. Some of the best-selling books of the last century were deemed lacking from a writing-quality standpoint by some publishers and yet sold millions by the one publisher who thought it was worthwhile. Of course, this doesn’t mean it was well-written after all, but a decision-maker made a quick, subjective decision that won or lost for the publisher or agent. The common bond of everyone in a decision-making position for a publisher or agency is that “you win some and you lose some”.

One of my favorite cartoons depicts a cocktail party of publishing people and each one was introduced as, “The guy who rejected John Grisham”, or “The person who thought Stephen King couldn’t write”, etc.   There are similar stories for every publisher, editor or agent in every age which all goes to prove the point of decisions being mostly subjective.

One area where change is seen is that most publishers place their marketing and sales leaders into the role of having virtual veto power over a prospective product. This is why an author platform is so important and sales data from similar products is such an issue today.  But with all the data available and emphasis on author platforms, decisions are still made quickly and subjectively.

Every new author feels deep in their bones that if an agent or publisher would simply take the time to review their work thoroughly that they would agree it is worthy of being represented and published.

That would be true if there were far fewer authors trying to be published. The sheer numbers require that everyone make a decision quickly based on a first impression.

Publishing is a lot more like hitting a baseball than shooting free-throws in basketball.  A great free-throw shooter (like Steve Laube in is heyday) could make up to 90% of their shots. A great baseball player might get a hit a third of the time.

(I can wedge examples from sports into just about any blog topic…amazing.)

This feels like I am deliberately trying to discourage a new author, which I am not, but think of it this way:

  • You only need one agent to agree to represent your work and there are a lot of us.
  • You only need one editor to like your work to get it considered and there are a lot of them.

Everyone doesn’t need to love what you do, just one or two of the right people.

Leave a Comment

36 Pieces of Advice about Writers Conferences

It is the height of the annual Fall writers conference season so I thought I would compile all the posts we have done over the past few years on the writers conference experience and book proposals. If bound in a single volume it would be a small booklet of over 20,000 words. The …

Read More

Book Concepts That Will Never Sell

As a public service to our agency clients and the general Christian publishing industry (but mostly because it is a real drag being serious all the time) here are some book concepts that will never sell.  Don’t even bother trying to develop them. I Never Knew You: Depressing Bible Verses …

Read More

Travel Woes? It Will be Okay!

As I prepare to attend the ACFW conference, I recall how many things can go wrong on travel. They can, and they do. But the world will not end. Please remember this. How do I know? Because I used to consider myself indispensable. But the graveyards are filled with indispensable …

Read More

Proposals: Make Comparison Titles Work for You

When I mention adding comp titles to a proposal, this is the response I often get from both nonfiction and fiction authors: “AARRRGGHH! Why? It’s so hard!” Well, there are two main reasons as to the why: Comp titles show there’s a market out there for books like yours. Comp …

Read More

Long Live Napoleon Solo

The middle of September 1964 was one of the most historic periods in world history.  Rarely has humanity seen the kind of cultural shift that occurred fifty years ago this month.  Subsequent generations will never be the same. In one week, families, friends, fiends, fish and fun boat-rides changed forever, …

Read More

How To Stumble Onto Your Brand…

Erin Taylor Young has a remarkable gift for making her readers laugh out loud even as she’s delivering hard truths about living a life of faith. Her down-to-earth writing style invites readers into the books that God has given her and sends them away refreshed and assured that we’re not …

Read More

Fun Friday – Sept. 12, 2014

The message in today’s video is so powerful that I had to share it. The message cuts to the core of why we work so hard in the publishing industry to tell stories, both fiction and non-fiction. To bring redemption, hope, and new life to those around us. This video was …

Read More

Novel Settings: City or Small Town?

Recently a faithful blog reader posted a question in response to my post on setting. She wondered why more Christian fiction isn’t set in large cities, and if there is a way to write the story to make a big city feel like a small town. Opportunity Versus Roots I grew …

Read More